9 pickers · every call on the record

They pick stocks on camera. We price every call. Who actually beats the market?

Consensus Alpha tracks 9 YouTube stock pickers, logs every explicit buy and sell they make on camera, and prices each call at that day's close. Every book is scored against the market it ran in — no cherry-picking, no hindsight edits, no exceptions for fan favorites.

See the scoreboard What the crowd holds

The scoreboard

full board →

1 ZipTrader
+124.4%
2 Dumb Money Live
+111.9%
3 Ticker Symbol: YOU
+64.5%
4 Felix & Friends (Goat Academy)
+60.1%
5 Everything Money
+49.5%

Growth of 100 in each tracked book, scored nightly against the market. Not advice.

Every call, on the record

Each video is transcribed and every explicit "I'm buying / I'm out" is logged to that picker's book — faithfully, with no cherry-picking and no hindsight edits.

Priced at the moment

Entries fill at the closing price on the day the call was made and mark to live quotes — so returns and hit rates are honest, not vibes.

What the crowd holds

When 4 tracked books land on the same stock it enters the consensus book — a live gauge of where YouTube conviction is crowding. A sentiment read, not a strategy: the overlap has trailed the market, and we publish that record too.

The Sunday brief

Once a week we synthesize everything the pickers said — where they agree, where they split, and what changed — into one readable memo for subscribers.

Consensus right now

full book →

AAPL
+21.1%
AMZN
+13.0%
GOOGL
+92.2%
PLTR
+110.0%
META
+5.5%

Where the pickers' books overlap right now — a crowding gauge, not a strategy. Not advice.

This week's brief

Aug 30 — Sep 06, 2026

AI infrastructure, power and software remain the favored buys despite rising geopolitical, rate and execution risks

Read the brief →

Get the weekly synthesis of everything the pickers said — free.

Subscribe